Should you give the statue to Benedict Halifax in GTA 6?
Yes, give Benedict Halifax the statue in GTA 6's Dubious Provenance. Refusing only delays the mission. Here's every Halifax choice and what each one leads to.
Reported. Established outlets report this. Rockstar hasn't said so.

Yes, give Benedict Halifax the statue. Refusing doesn't change how Dubious Provenance plays out: you have to hand it over eventually to finish the mission, so saying no just makes it take longer.
Halifax gives you two more choices before the mission is over, and both have a better answer too. Here's each one in order.
Starting Dubious Provenance
Dubious Provenance is the fourth story mission of Chapter 3 (see our full GTA 6 mission list for where it sits). It's built around the bronze statuette Jason and Lucia picked up in Chapter 1 along with the hard drive.
- Play until Cal visits the Bayside apartment you're borrowing from Boobie to look at the hard drive.
- Once Cal leaves, look for a statuette icon at the closet door.
- Interact with it to start the mission.
- Drive to Capri, the upscale town on the far side of the map, and go to the antiques store.
In the store, Evelyn Andrews turns the statue down because it's obviously stolen. Then art dealer Benedict Halifax pulls you aside and offers to get it appraised. That's your first choice.
Choice 1: give Halifax the statue or keep it
| Choice | What happens |
|---|---|
| Give him the statue | He gives you a watch to hold as collateral while he gets it appraised. Then he disappears and avoids you. |
| Keep the statue | You hold onto it for now, but the mission can't move forward. To continue, you have to call Halifax from your contacts or go back to Capri and give it to him anyway. |
Give it to him. Either way, the mission ends up in the same place.
After the handover, Halifax won't take your calls and every attempt goes to voicemail. That's part of the story, not a bug. Do other missions and activities until Jason and Lucia decide to go looking for him in Capri, which happens as part of the main mission, so you can't miss it.
Choice 2: give Halifax more time or take the statue back
When you track Halifax down at a motel, he asks to keep the statue a bit longer.
- Give him more time: this unlocks the third and final part of Dubious Provenance, along with its rewards.
- Take the statue back: the mission stops there and ends early.
Let him keep it.
Choice 3: kill or spare Halifax
Eventually Evelyn gets in touch about Halifax, and you go back to Capri for the last part of the mission. After a long chase, you corner Halifax and hold him at gunpoint.
Spare him. Don't press R2 (the PlayStation fire button; the Xbox button hasn't been listed) and let the cutscene finish.
- Killing him counts as violence against a civilian, so it damages your Criminal Profile, and it brings the police after you.
- Sparing him lets you search his garage for free cash, jewelry and his custom Vapid '32 Hustler.
You can keep the Hustler for $21,900 or sell it for $5,825. Game Rant suggests selling it for the extra cash. For other ways to boost your bank balance, see our GTA 6 money guide, and our cars and vehicles list covers the rest of the garage.
Written by AI from the sources listed here, then checked automatically for copied wording and for claims stronger than the sources. How we work





