GTA 6 news, rumours and guides, updated around the clock

GTA 6 is out now on PS5 and Xbox Series X|S

Tracking 32 sources

Loading search

GTA 6: kill or spare Arnold? Why sparing him pays off

Hey Arnold! ends with GTA 6's first big moral choice. Here's what killing or sparing Arnold does to your Criminal Profile, and why letting him go is better.

Reported. Established outlets report this. Rockstar hasn't said so.

Man in a sleeveless shirt holds a pistol beside a woman sitting on a red car, with palm trees, a hotel and a plane at sunset.
Image: Rockstar Games

Hey Arnold! ends with the first real moral choice in GTA 6's story: do you kill Brian's business partner Arnold, or let him walk? The short answer is to spare him. It costs you nothing, it adds to the Restrained side of your Criminal Profile, and Arnold comes back in a later mission. Kill him and all you get is a darker profile.

Where Hey Arnold! fits in the story

Hey Arnold! is the seventh mission of Chapter 1 and comes after Pipework, the mission where you meet Mandy. Arnold has gone quiet on Brian, so Jason, Brian and Cal head to the radar station near the Aerostat to find him. Arnold doesn't like how Brian runs his drug business, and after a short argument he and his crew jump into a pickup truck and take off.

That starts a high-speed car chase with plenty of shooting. Follow the truck to the Key Lento Marina, where Arnold ditches it. Brian tells Jason to "shut him up", and when it comes to how, all he adds is "Do whatever you have to do." Then you chase Arnold on foot. The chase ends when you tackle him or he runs out of pier, and he begs for his life, saying he wants to quit crime and disappear.

For where this mission sits among the rest, see our full GTA 6 story mission list.

How to spare Arnold

  1. Once Arnold is cornered on the pier, hold L2/LT to interact with him.
  2. Press X/A to pick Spare.

Jason scares him with a threat and lets him go. Arnold slinks off and Brian never finds out. Sparing him adds to the Restrained side of your Criminal Profile, and Arnold turns up again in a later mission, so this is the choice that gets you more story.

You can also just do nothing. If you wait without choosing, Arnold leaves on his own, and the game treats it as if you had spared him.

How to kill Arnold, and what it costs

There are two ways to kill him, and they don't count the same way:

How you kill himCriminal Profile result
Execute him with your gun when he begs on the pierA warning that "Indiscriminate violence will contribute toward a violent criminal profile", counting toward the Hardened Criminal rating
Shoot him or his truck during the car chaseCounts toward a Ruthless profile, and skips the foot chase and the begging

Killing him during the chase is the fastest way through the mission if that's all you care about.

Does the choice change anything else?

Not much. The Criminal Profile is GTA 6's morality system, and it mostly tracks how often you kill people, so this choice pushes yours one way or the other. Either way, the cutscene that follows is the same. Sparing Arnold has no downside and killing him earns you nothing, so letting him go is the better pick unless you're deliberately building a ruthless Jason. For more on who Brian, Cal and the rest of the cast are, see our GTA 6 characters guide.

Sources: PC Gamer, GamesRadar+

Written by AI from the sources listed here, then checked automatically for copied wording and for claims stronger than the sources. How we work

Also available in Español, Português

Keep reading