GTA 6 ties Ocarina of Time at 99, but Zelda still edges it
GTA 6 sits at number one on Metacritic's all-time list with a 99, level with Ocarina of Time. The unrounded math still gives Zelda a narrow lead.
Reported. Established outlets report this. Rockstar hasn't said so.

GTA 6 now sits at the top of Metacritic's list of the best games of all time with a critic score of 99 out of 100. It shares that score with The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, the 1998 Nintendo 64 classic that has held the crown for decades. Look past the rounded number, though, and Link's adventure still comes out slightly ahead.
The two games are well clear of everyone else. Soul Calibur, Super Mario Galaxy 2 and GTA IV follow on 98, so the argument over the top spot is a two-horse race.
Why Ocarina still has the edge
Metacritic lists GTA 6 first, but by HobbyConsolas' arithmetic on the individual reviews, Ocarina's unrounded average is the higher one. The gap is a fraction of a point, and it shows up in three places:
| GTA 6 | Ocarina of Time | |
|---|---|---|
| Critic reviews counted | About 150 | Just over 20 |
| Unrounded average | 98.70% (about 14,804 of 15,000 points) | 98.95% (around 2,377 of 2,400 points) |
| Share of perfect 100s | About 80% | About 82% |
| Scores below 95 | Ten 90s and one 80 | One 90 |
GTA 6's much bigger sample works both ways. Holding a 99 across roughly 150 reviews is a harder feat than doing it across two dozen, and Ocarina's count is small partly because many reviews from 1998 were never added to Metacritic. But those extra reviews also brought in the handful of 90s and the lone 80 that pull Rockstar's average just under Nintendo's.
For the full breakdown of how critics scored the game, see our GTA 6 reviews and Metacritic score guide.
A rematch at The Game Awards
The two may meet again. The Game Awards names its Game of the Year 2026 on December 10, and GTA 6 and Ocarina of Time Remake are widely seen as the favourites among the six nominees. This time Link comes back as a remake rather than the 1998 original, and the jury picks one winner, so a tie is off the table.
New to the game or catching up? Our GTA 6 hub covers everything else about Rockstar's latest.
Sources: HobbyConsolas
Written by AI from the sources listed here, then checked automatically for copied wording and for claims stronger than the sources. How we work






